---
title: Five line items we flag on water-loss estimates | Old School
description: "Equipment past the drying logs, Cat 3 pricing on cleaner losses, duplicate labor, unit costs and tax: what to check and what to ask the contractor."
---

CONFERENCE [Meet the Old School team at \[CONFERENCE NAME\], \[CITY\], \[DATES\]. Book a time →](https://www.oldschool-us.com/insights#events)

[![Old School]()](https://www.oldschool-us.com/?hsLang=en)

[What we do](https://www.oldschool-us.com/what-we-do?hsLang=en) [Desk Review](https://www.oldschool-us.com/desk-review?hsLang=en) [Insights](https://www.oldschool-us.com/insights?hsLang=en) [Team](https://www.oldschool-us.com/team?hsLang=en) [Contact](https://www.oldschool-us.com/contact?hsLang=en) 

[Start a desk review](https://www.oldschool-us.com/desk-review/start?hsLang=en)

[← Field notes](https://www.oldschool-us.com/insights?hsLang=en)

ESTIMATE WATCH

# Five line items we question on nearly every water-loss estimate

None of these mean the contractor is wrong. Each is a question worth asking before you settle, and the drying logs, photos and invoices usually answer it.

\[Author\], Old School\[Publish date\]5 min read

![Flooded street after a storm](https://osvpm.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/water.jpeg)

IN THIS ARTICLE

[01 · Equipment billed beyond the drying log](https://www.oldschool-us.com/insights/five-line-items-water-loss#i1)[02 · Category 3 pricing on a Category 1 or 2 loss](https://www.oldschool-us.com/insights/five-line-items-water-loss#i2)[03 · Duplicate labor across tasks](https://www.oldschool-us.com/insights/five-line-items-water-loss#i3)[04 · Unit costs that exceed the price list](https://www.oldschool-us.com/insights/five-line-items-water-loss#i4)[05 · Sales tax on labor and equipment](https://www.oldschool-us.com/insights/five-line-items-water-loss#i5)

**Have an estimate open right now?**Upload it and see what we'd flag, free.[Free preview →](https://www.oldschool-us.com/desk-review/start?hsLang=en)

We review a lot of mitigation estimates. The same five patterns come up again and again, and they're the first things our software looks for before an expert reads the file. Here's what they are, why they happen, and what to ask.

01

## Equipment billed beyond the drying log

Dehumidifiers and air movers are billed by the day. When the moisture readings show the structure was dry on day six and the estimate carries equipment for fourteen, the difference is worth a conversation.

Length matters for rates, too. On a three-day dry-out there's little to check. Past about five days, daily rental rates should usually step down to weekly rates, and long dry-outs deserve a line-by-line look at weekly and monthly pricing.

ASK THE CONTRACTORCan you send the daily moisture readings? Which day did each room reach its drying goal, and when was each unit pulled?

02

## Category 3 pricing on a Category 1 or 2 loss

Water category drives a lot of cost: hazmat technicians, PPE, antimicrobials, disposal. Category 3 (black water) work is priced accordingly. When the cause of loss was a supply line and the records point to Category 1 or 2, those lines should be repriced, often to general labor.

The category is a judgment call made from the cause of loss and the moisture and drying records, which is why an expert, not software, makes the final call here.

ASK THE CONTRACTORWhat category did you document on day one, and what changed it? Do you have photos or test results that support it?

> “The question isn't whether the contractor did the work. It's whether the file shows it.”

\[ATTRIBUTION\]

03

## Duplicate labor across tasks

Duplicate effort is rarely obvious because it hides across tasks. A common example: hourly technician time for equipment setup and monitoring, on top of a daily monitoring charge that already covers the same visits.

ASK THE CONTRACTORWhich visits does the daily monitoring charge cover, and what work do the separate technician hours cover that it doesn't?

04

## Unit costs that exceed the price list

Xactimate prices come from a local price list, but a unit cost can be edited line by line. When a handful of lines exceed the list for that area and month, ask why. Sometimes there's a good reason; sometimes it's a habit.

ASK THE CONTRACTORWhich price list and month did you use? For each line priced above it, what drove the change?

05

## Sales tax on labor and equipment

In many states, Xactimate applies sales tax to materials, not to labor. Tax showing up on labor or equipment lines is easy to miss and simple to correct, once you check the state's rule.

ASK THE CONTRACTORWhich tax rate did you apply, and to which line types?

## The short version

Check the equipment days against the drying logs, the category against the cause of loss, and the unit costs against the price list. Look for hours that show up twice and tax where it doesn't belong. And keep the settlement decision yours: the point of a second look is a clearer conversation, not a fight.

DESK REVIEW

## We check all five, and the rest, in 72 hours.

Our software and field experts review every line together, so your position is objective and defensible. Flat fee from $1,500.

[Upload for a free preview](https://www.oldschool-us.com/desk-review/start?hsLang=en)[How the Desk Review works](https://www.oldschool-us.com/desk-review?hsLang=en)

## Keep reading

[All field notes →](https://www.oldschool-us.com/insights?hsLang=en)

[![Flood waters around buildings](https://osvpm.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/flood.jpeg) ESTIMATE WATCHDaily versus weekly equipment rates](https://www.oldschool-us.com/insights?hsLang=en) [![Firefighters at work](https://osvpm.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/firemen.jpeg) ESTIMATE WATCHWater category and the cost it carries](https://www.oldschool-us.com/insights?hsLang=en) [![Building on fire](https://osvpm.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/fire-bldg.jpeg) MITIGATIONEmergency mitigation versus early reconstruction](https://www.oldschool-us.com/insights?hsLang=en)

OLD SCHOOL

Vendor and project management for commercial property losses. On call 24/7/365.

SERVICES

[Damage assessments](https://www.oldschool-us.com/what-we-do#assessments)[Scope of work](https://www.oldschool-us.com/what-we-do#scope)[Project management](https://www.oldschool-us.com/what-we-do#pm)[Scope & cost auditing](https://www.oldschool-us.com/what-we-do#audit)[Desk Review (fixed price)](https://www.oldschool-us.com/desk-review?hsLang=en)

COMPANY

[Leadership](https://www.oldschool-us.com/team?hsLang=en)[Insights](https://www.oldschool-us.com/insights?hsLang=en)[Events](https://www.oldschool-us.com/insights#events)[Contact](https://www.oldschool-us.com/contact?hsLang=en)

CALL ANYTIME

[470-282-3970](tel:4702823970)

5805 State Bridge Rd, Suite G109  
Duluth, GA 30097

30 Haynes Circle  
Chicopee, MA 01020

© Old School Vendor & Project Management, LLC. All rights reserved.VENDOR & PROJECT MANAGEMENT